Leading People
Gerry Murray talks to leading people about leading people. Get insights and tips from thought leaders about how to bring out the best in yourself and others.
Leading People
You Said It. But Did You Communicate It?
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
How often have you walked away from a meeting thinking, “I explained that perfectly,” only to discover later that somebody heard something completely different?
We often judge communication by what we said, sent or presented.
But is that really where communication happens?
In this reflection episode of Leading People, Gerry Murray revisits conversations with Ray Walsh, Dee Clayton, Michael Reddington and Liam FitzPatrick to explore what happens between sending a message and having it truly land.
What does your audience actually hear?
What meaning do they make from what you say?
How much are you learning while you communicate?
And how do people know that you have really listened?
Four different perspectives come together around one deceptively simple idea: communication is about much more than getting the message out.
If you lead people, influence others, present ideas or simply want your conversations to have more impact, this episode offers plenty to reflect on.
Enjoyed this episode? The Leading People Community is where these conversations continue to flourish.
Free to join — Book reviews, Leading People Café recordings, Podcast episode previews, and a growing group of active HR and L&D professionals, leaders, and coaches who take their work seriously.
Join the Leading People Community
Connect with Gerry on LinkedIn
Why Clear Messages Still Miss
SPEAKER_03Welcome to Leading People with me, Jerry Murray. This is the podcast for HR leaders, LD professionals, and senior leaders who want to bring out the best in themselves and the people around them. Every other week I sit down with leading authors, researchers, and practitioners for deep, honest conversations about what great leadership actually looks like in practice. And how your own mindset, behavior, and presence shape everything around you. If you want thinking that challenges you, tools you can use, and conversations worth returning to, you're in the right place. How often have you walked away from a meeting thinking, I explained that perfectly? Only to discover later that someone heard something completely different. Or perhaps they understood what you said, but didn't understand what you meant. Or they understood both, but didn't do anything differently afterwards. Now we tend to think about communication from our own side of the equation. What did I say? Did I explain it clearly? Did I send the email? Did I make the presentation? But perhaps none of those things tell us whether communication has actually happened. Now one of the great privileges of hosting this podcast is that I get to sit down and have thought-provoking and insightful conversations with some of the best thinkers on the topic of leading people. And as I looked back through some of those conversations, I noticed something interesting. Four guests approaching communication from very different directions seemed to be challenging the same assumption. Ray Walsh has spent much of his career in international corporate communications. Dee Clayton specializes in helping people communicate and present more effectively. Michael Reddington came to leadership communication through the slightly unusual world of forensic interviewing, and Liam Fitzpatrick has spent decades advising organizations on employee and internal communication. Different worlds, but a common question is communication really about what we say? Because sending a message is one thing, having it land is something else entirely.
The Broadcast Myth In Organisations
SPEAKER_03So let's start with Ray Walsh.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, there's it I think one problem is that we have departments called communication, uh, when in fact everybody in the organization communicates. And and when they're in school, they learn about the importance of communication skills, but then they get into an organization and they find they have this department that specializes in it, specializes in it. You know, something like the department of breathing. Well, you know, everybody breathes, but you know, we're but we're the ones that know how to do it underwater or with uh scuba tanks or whatever. We have specialized skills, but no, nevertheless, that that's sort of a default setting, I think, in people. They even with small startups, they think that there's, well, that's the function of communications. They will disseminate the organization. And I think we in communications, we have the same idea. Uh in my mind, it's a bit of an old-fashioned notion. You know, we are at headquarters, we are the central newsroom. We broadcast and you receive. And I've seen this mindset so many times in in capable and intelligent leaders who think that, well, the CEO did a video, so everybody must have seen it because that's their job. Well, in fact, people have, you know, a million things to do and they're distracted. Or even if they watched it, maybe they were multitasking, they didn't quite catch the message, or it just didn't occur to them how it really uh resonates or you know, how it connects to their job directly. So, yeah, communication, it's a bit of a, you know, it means different things to different people. And, you know, and I think that um I I think if I want business people to know one thing, I want to dispel that notion that, you know, just because we sent that email, we produced that video, that somehow the notion has been communicated. I think it's probably better to think about communications as sort of advertising air cover. You know, uh uh somebody once told me, you know, uh he's he's a Londoner. Uh, sometimes when I take the tube, I see advertisements, but I don't I don't take the tube to see advertisements. You know, they're just they're not going to our channels uh, you know, in order to consume them. Um so yeah, I mean, uh I mean uh I've seen benchmarks, a lot of organizations in some industries, there'll be uh, you know, you can expect, like, let's say, for example, a 50% open rate in email. It it varies by communication, it varies by organization. I would say really, we probably more realistically expect 20% of the people to read the message. And then the next question is were they the right people? Did they understand it? Did it connect? Uh it, you know, there's so I think that there's there's another aspect of communication, and that's the most important one, and that's peer-to-peer, you know, manager to team, that person-to-person connection. That's really the glue that's going to hold all of our communications together. And the formal stuff that, you know, people like uh, you know, communication departments produce, that's just more the advertising air cover that reinforces that core message. And too often organizations rely on the communications department when it should be, you know, the other way around.
SPEAKER_03I like Ray's analogy of advertising air cover. The email may exist, the video may have been published, and the presentation may have been delivered, but none of that tells us whether anybody has actually made meaning from it. And that becomes even more interesting when you think about leadership. Because perhaps the test of communication isn't whether I said what I intended to say, perhaps the test is what happened at the other end. Ray gave a great example of what that can look like inside an organization.
Translating Strategy Into Daily Work
SPEAKER_00Yeah, there's there's so many levels to that. You know, the you know, when you're the plant manager working in Belgium or Germany or or or or Mexico, a message that comes to you in English flags itself as corporate. And even you may have the best of intentions to get back to it eventually, but today you've got other stuff to do. It's it's definitely a message from a place far, far away. So it has a second kind of priority. That's that's number one. And then number two, just as you're saying, you know, what is the interpretation of that message? Uh, you know, you know, did they take in all of the uh you know, all of the nuances? You know, I can give you a specific example of how that might break down. So I was with an organization that was expanding into a new uh industry vertical for them. It was healthcare. Uh, and it was much more profitable than their uh you know traditional business line. So we in the communications department, we were producing lots of content about healthcare, how it's a strategic industry for us, how we're you know really well positioned to serve this industry, uh, article after article. Uh and then I heard through the grapevine of an incident where you know the sales group had taken a particular uh a specific uh um request for a proposal to the pricing department. And the pricing department is to figure out how much are we going to charge for this service? Well, a few weeks went by, sales hadn't heard anything, they started to get panicky, they got on the horn, and it turns out the pricing department were doing as they always had. There was a queue of projects that needed to be priced, and it was deeper in the queue, and they were going to get to it as time allowed. And the salespeople said, Don't you realize that that one healthcare bid is gonna be more profitable for us than the rest of your stack put together? So, you know, so so what happened? How did that break down? You know, I don't know if they read our articles or not. Uh maybe they did, maybe they didn't. But what had what had failed to happen is that uh it hadn't been interpreted for them. So you can see these top-level messages that healthcare is important, it's a strategic industry for us. But what does that mean to us in the pricing department? And what does that mean specifically to me in my role? That in my mind takes a human being, a manager, a leader to interpret. You know, did you see this content? Did you see this speech or this presentation? This is what it means for us this year, this is what it means for us this quarter, and then one-on-one, this is what it means for you. Uh and I that that that level of communication is so important, and and organizations and leaders can't be passive and assume that the articles are somehow going to provide the cover they need.
SPEAKER_03Now that distinction feels important. What does this mean for us? And then what does this mean for me? A corporate message may be perfectly clear at headquarters and still be almost meaningless when it arrives somewhere else in the organization. Somebody has to make that translation, sometimes literally.
Presenting For The Audience Not You
SPEAKER_03And that same principle applies when we stand in front of an audience. Because the temptation is still to begin with what I want to say. When I spoke with Dee Clayton about presenting, she turned that around.
SPEAKER_01Well, you know, presenting is your chance to influence many people at once. So some people are very good at influencing on a one-to-one basis, which is great, a really good skill. And generally, the higher up the ladder you go, the more people you need to influence in one go. That might be a whole organization, it might be a whole series of listeners to your podcast, it could be uh I saw I went onto Google something or other, uh, Google Drive the other day, and they said one billion users. I I can't even, I don't even kind of get that that kind of number. But you know, if you're in a huge organization, you need to you can't just influence on a one-to-one basis. You need to influence on a group basis, but we need to feel like it's a one-to-one basis. So you've listened to people and heard people who, I'm sure as they're speaking, you think they're talking straight to me. But you know there's another hundred or thousand people listening on the webinar or podcast or whatever, but you feel that they're talking right to you. And that's the that's that connection, that's that ability to influence people. If you can speak on a one-to-one basis, but you're in a group of many, so influence is important.
SPEAKER_03Now I think there's a useful paradox in that. You may be speaking to a hundred people or a thousand or an entire organization, but every member of that audience is still experiencing your communication at an individual level. And that raises a very different question from what do I want to tell them, to what do they need from me? Later in our conversation, Dee made that distinction very explicit.
SPEAKER_01Very good. So assuming you've now got rid of your monkeys and you can just do the presentation as you should be doing it, then the main thing really is to think about what the audience wants to hear. And so many people are presenting and talking about themselves all the time. Uh, you know, it's a bit different in this interview because you asked you asked me and you're introducing me into the into the interview, and it is an interview, which is different from a presentation. But normally at the beginning of a presentation, I wouldn't spend any time really talking about me other than to build enough credibility that they want to listen to me. The rest of it's about you. How are you doing? What will you get from this presentation? Why why will you benefit from listening to this presentation? What's in it for you? If you've heard of Wiffham in that, you know, the old sales stuff, what's in it for me? So turning the whole thing on its head, Jerry, and thinking about the audience first and saying, What do you want? The audience, you know, how how can I add value to you? And then giving them the content in a structure that is useful for them, and then um putting it in an actionable, what what what what action do I want my audience to do? Which is the how section in the what I call the simply amazing structure. And the how section is often missed out. People just do a presentation and then they say goodbye. Well, you're sitting there going, Well, that was a lovely presentation, but I've no idea I've no idea what I've got to do now. There's no action for me to take. There's nothing I need to do differently. And then people come back the week and go, Well, haven't you done that, Jerry? And you're like, No, I didn't you didn't ask me to do anything. Yes, I did. I gave a whole presentation on it. Uh well, you gave a whole presentation, but you didn't actually get round to saying what you want us to do with it, right? So that's a huge section that most presentations don't have a how section, uh an afters section. As there's a great author called Andy Bowns, and he talks about it being called afters. What are people left with after you've finished?
SPEAKER_03So what are people left with after you've finished? That feels like a pretty useful test of communication. Not did I get through my slides or did I say everything I wanted to say. But what happened for them, for the audience? What did they understand? What will they now do differently? And there's another implication in everything we've heard so far. To know whether something is landing, we need information coming back in the other direction. Which means communication cannot only be about speaking, it has to involve listening. And that brings us to Michael Reddington.
Subscribe And Join The Community
SPEAKER_03But first, we'll be right back after this short break. If you're finding value in this conversation, please subscribe wherever you listen to your podcasts, and perhaps share this episode with a colleague who'd find it useful. Word of mouth is how good podcasts grow. And if you'd like to be part of the conversation beyond the podcast, I'd love to have you in the leading people community, a growing group of HR leaders, LD professionals, and experienced leaders who gather regularly for live sessions, discussions, and the kind of thinking you've been hearing today. You'll find the details in the show notes.
Listening Equals Learning For Leaders
SPEAKER_03Michael Reddington's professional background is somewhat unusual. Before moving into executive work, he spent years as a certified forensic interviewer. What fascinated him wasn't simply how to get somebody to admit something, it was what was happening inside the other person's head that made them willing to share information they might otherwise protect. And when Michael started working with leaders, he realized that many of the same principles applied. And one phrase from our conversation really stuck with me. Listening equals learning.
SPEAKER_04Listening equals learning. If we're not learning, we're not listening. And all too often, as leaders, it's very easy for us to fall into the entitlement trap. Based on our success, based on our education, based on everything we've achieved, based on our status, we believe that we are entitled to what everybody knows. We believe that we are entitled to what everybody else is supposed to do. We believe that we're entitled to be privy to other people's decision-making processes. When in reality, often those around us feel entitled to protect themselves and serve themselves. And to the degree that that also helps us, great. But to the degree that it doesn't, they're going to default to protecting and serving themselves both. So now more than ever, of course, it's more imperative for leaders to listen because we there's a whole new learning curve for us to go. How are we going to reconnect? How are we going to capitalize on the situation? How are we going to not just build relationships, but rebuild relationships? And one more way, I suppose that we could say the script, I don't know that the script has been flipped in this case, but it has certainly been exacerbated. People, in my opinion, more than ever, are incentivized not to listen. We are literally now more than ever incentivized to pick a side. I am right, you are wrong, I am this, you are that. You said one thing, I don't agree anymore. So any number of labels that we can put on it. So from a leadership standpoint, if we if we commit ourselves to listening with the learning mentality, if we commit ourselves to identifying hidden value, if we commit ourselves to creating these opportunities to learn and connect with others, we literally might be the only people within a population that's doing that, which enhances the value that people see in us. And to your point, enhances how people feel about themselves and feel about our relationship and what they're willing to do. So that answer got a touch long-winded. But there's there's an incalculable amount of benefits there.
SPEAKER_03Now there's something challenging in Michael's idea of the entitlement trap. The more experienced we become, perhaps the easier it is to enter a conversation believing we already understand what's going on. We know this person, we know this team, we know this problem, and we know what they're going to say. But if I already know how the conversation ends, how carefully am I really going to listen to what happens along the way? Michael described a rather different approach.
SPEAKER_04And to give you more credit, I was trying to be as patient as I could. You perfectly set up the first behavior for participating in the conversation, which is allow the conversation to come to you. And that's exactly what you were just talking about. Letting somebody else speak, taking the opportunity to learn. Anytime we go into a conversation saying, I've got this all figured out, stop. There's always something that we don't know. There's always something that we can learn. Whether it's a fact, a perspective, an emotion, there's always something that we can learn. If we're not listening, we're not learning. If somebody else isn't speaking, we're not learning. So letting the conversation come to us is extremely important. Giving somebody the opportunity to talk in depth and explain gives us plenty of opportunity to listen, not just for information, but for intelligence. During that process, it is very important that we observe the totality of their communication to the degree, depending on the modality. Is it email, phone call, video call? Are we sitting face to face in a pub or a coffee shop? Preferably a pub, if I'm being honest. To the degree that we have it available in front of us, I want to observe the totality of my audience's communication, verbal and nonverbal. And I want to observe that not for truth and lie. And I don't teach many investigators anymore, but when I do, I still reinforce this with investigators, not just executives and sales teams. I don't want to observe for indications of truth and lie. I want to observe for indications of comfort and discomfort. While you are talking to me, I want to look for changes in your comfort level. Are things that you're describing to me appearing to increase or decrease your comfort level? As I'm talking to you, I want to look and listen for changes in your comfort level based on what I'm saying. Most, the vast majority of the behavioral shifts that we have the opportunity to observe are driven by an internal emotional shift. And the greater the emotional shift is on the inside, the stronger the behavior changes on the outside. So when we talk about listening or observing for intelligence over information, I will also say this when a behavior changes is far more important than what behavior changes. So, really, what I want to do is I want to be keen on where and how is your behavior changing in relation to the topic of the conversation or what is happening around us in the room. That's what allows me to really get between somebody's ears and be very confident in my interpretation of what they're thinking or feeling in the moment. It's that contextual awareness. So we're not trying to catch somebody lying. Generally speaking, most of the things that can happen if we try to catch somebody lying are bad or at least not productive. So we want to look and listen for those changes in comfort levels. Once we observe those, we get to the next behavior, which is adapt our approach. We don't want to stay married to a suboptimal conversational approach as we're gathering this new intelligence and we're learning more. The more we learn, the more we can adapt. Do I need to press forward a little bit stronger? Do I need to step away? Do I need to shift topics altogether? Do I need to call a break? Do I need to get somebody else involved in the conversation? There's any number of decisions we can make. And then the last one for engaging during the conversation could likely be the linchpin to this entire process. Always encourage your counterparts to protect their self-image. The literal key, the biggest motivating factor that helps people share any type of sensitive information or change their behavior in any way, share information in any way that makes them feel vulnerable, is to help them save face and protect their self-image. So we should be going out of our way to avoid making people feel embarrassed, to avoid making people feel threatened, to avoid making people feel stupid. I mean, fill in your negative word of choice. We should be going out of our way in our conversations to help people save face and protect their self-image.
SPEAKER_03Now I think that introduces another dimension. Communication isn't simply two people exchanging information. There's emotion in the room, there's identity, there's sometimes vulnerability, and there's the other person's need to protect how they see themselves. And if I'm so focused on delivering Delivering my message that I fail to notice what's happening for the other person, I may technically have communicated very clearly while making it almost impossible for them to hear me. Which takes us from individual conversations back into organizations.
Internal Comms As A Two Way Bridge
SPEAKER_03When I spoke with Liam Fitzpatrick, he described internal communication as a bridge. And as we all know, a bridge works in both directions.
SPEAKER_02That's a really important question, actually, because there are kind of two or three different ways into it. There's the piece that I do, which is about saying internal communications is the bridge, is a bridge. It bridges between an organization and the people it wants to talk to. And that's about a process of making sure that everyone has a shared context, that we're all pointing in the right direction, but also making sure the leaders in the organization have a reliable intelligence source about what's really working out there in the organization. Are you know what are people saying? It's a two-way process, so you're a bridge between the two points. The other element to it is actually enabling people in the organization to have great conversations, particularly managers. Um, the bulk of great internal communications really relies on the role of leaders to translate corporate messages into something that makes sense on a day-to-day basis for their teams. And one of the key parts of internal communications is actually helping leaders have those conversations, providing them with the training, the coaching, the tools, and the insights they need to do that job properly.
SPEAKER_03There's that word again. Translate. Ray talked about translating strategy into what it means for me. Dee talked about starting off with what the audience needs. And Michael talked about listening and adapting as we learn more. And now Liam is reminding us that communication inside an organization is supposed to bring intelligence back up the chain, as well as messages down the chain. But perhaps people only believe that communication is genuinely two-way when they see evidence that somebody is actually listening. Liam told a wonderful story about that.
A CEO Who Listens And Acts
SPEAKER_02And in the space of 18 months, we went from 55,000 to 15, as bits of the business were sold off, bits of the business were closed down, and it was really tough going. And then news got out that the chief executive was, when we restructured the debt, the chief executive was in line for a multi-million pound bonus if he clawed back some or regained some of the value that he lost to the shelves. If you go out there and start talking to it, they're going to stab you. And he said, No, I'm not. I'm going to go and tell them. I'm going to go and tell them what we did. So he went and did these town hall meetings, and he'd stand up and he'd go, he'd start talking about the business strategy. And it's one lead, sooner or later, someone would put their hand up and go, uh, Mike, can you tell us how wonderful you are? And then another middle manager would put their hand up and go, Mike, my mic, surely you're more wonderful than that. And then eventually, some beardy engineer would put his hand up and go, excuse me, Mike, can I just check something out here? So I'm not a paywriter for three years. Half my friends have lost their jobs, and you're going to get a two million pound bonus, or 20 million pound bonus. Can you just talk me through that? And he'd go, Yeah, uh, yeah, of course I thought you threw it. But let me just say it's not fair, it's not equitable. Uh, but let me know tell you what I've got to do to get that bonus. Um, and he talked them through it, and he said, and I wasn't gonna be offered that bonus and go home to my wife and go, I've just been offered 20 million pounds, I'm not gonna take it though. He said, Well, I've got to earn it, and if I earn it, these things will happen, and everyone benefits and stuff like that. But it's not fair, and I'm not telling you it's equitable. And you get asked the same question three or four times, and people come out of those sessions and go, it's not fair, it's not equitable, but fair play, he was willing to listen to our complaints about it, and you could see where he'd been in the company just by the scores on things like uh, or the pulse scores about things like people feeling they had a future in the business. You could people had an emotional reaction to him. And what he would do is he would just go out and talk to people, just go and chat to them. He'd been willing to take any type of crap they threw at him, and he'd just say he was pretty clear about what he was doing, why he was doing it. He didn't give anyone any BS about what he was trying to do and who he was. But he would also go, hmm, okay, that's interesting. I hadn't thought of that. And he would go and act on things that people said to him. So one thing he did, we sent him out and he did a back to the floor exercise where he worked alongside some some guys installing equipment in a client's site. And um the guys opened the boxes and they kept saying to him, Look, Mike, every time these boxes come from the factory, half the stuff's not in them. And he goes, Okay. And he came back next day. He had a meeting and he said, I just worked out why our customers aren't paying us, because the factory aren't selling, sending the complete stock to the so we don't have any installations, so we need to fix that. And the result was that employees saw that when they had a conversation with him, he would take it away and fix stuff. And it just the morale in this company that went from you know 55,000 people to 15,000, the morale just went up, yeah, fantastic. People really were proud to work there again after two, three years of crap. And and it was just his personal behavior and his personal demeanour about just being willing to listen to people and just be present in a conversation.
SPEAKER_03I think that story captures something important. The CEO didn't communicate effectively because he found the perfect words. In fact, he couldn't make the situation fair. He couldn't make people like everything they heard. What he could do was turn up, explain, listen, acknowledge. And when people told him something useful, do something with it. That gives us a rather different definition of communication from the one we often use. It isn't simply about transferring information from one person to another, it involves meaning, context, attention, emotion, and listening, and ultimately some evidence that what has been heard matters. Liam summed that up beautifully later in our conversation.
SPEAKER_02I don't know if you've come across her. There's a British woman called Catherine Mannix, she's a doctor, and uh she wrote a couple of books, she specializes in palliative care, and she has very, very difficult conversations with patients all the time. And she wrote a brilliant book a few years ago called With the End in Mind, where she talks about the process you go through as a patient when you're faced facing the ultimate, you know, the ultimate bad news. And she brought out a book last year called Listen, um, which is a book based on her experiences over the years, both working in palliative care and drawing on you know advice and other aspects, um parts of all. And it's full of really great advice on how you strike up a conversation with someone, uh, a meaningful and curious conversation where you're actually willing to listen to what people have got to say and you're gonna react on it. And I'd said earlier, um, I don't know who said it originally, I think I heard it attributed to John Lennon, Monts Mike, and someone else. And it was a phrase something like being listened to is as close to love as many of us ever experience. And and I think for corporations that don't invest time in listening, uh, you're missing a massive trick. So teaching leaders to listen, teaching them to helping them have curious conversations, uh, not necessarily to be the guys who always got the answer. Um sometimes that's all people want. They just don't want the answer. They quite often just want someone who's going to hear them.
SPEAKER_03Someone who's going to hear them. Perhaps that's a good place to leave this.
Questions To Test Real Communication
SPEAKER_03We started with a simple question. You said it, but did you communicate it? Ray reminded us that sending something doesn't mean it has been received or understood. D shifted our attention from what the speaker wants to say to what the audience actually needs. Michael challenged us to listen with the intention of learning, rather than entering every conversation convinced we already know what is going on. And Liam reminded us that communication only becomes genuinely two-way when people experience being heard. So, perhaps the next time you have an important message to communicate, there are a few questions worth asking yourself. Not only what do I want to say, but what might they hear? What will this mean in their world? What am I willing to learn from their response? And perhaps more importantly, how will they know that I really listened? And on that note, thank you for listening to this reflection edition of Leading People.
Final Subscribe And Share
SPEAKER_03And that's it for this episode of Leading People. If you're new here and enjoyed today's conversation, I'd love it if you subscribed. It's the best way to make sure you never miss an episode. And if you are a regular listener, the best recommendation is always a personal one. So, if this episode made an impact on you, please share it with a friend or colleague. It might just be the best thing they listen to this week. Until next time.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Josh Bersin Company
Josh Bersin
McKinsey Talks Talent
McKinsey People & Organizational Performance
The News Agents
Global
The News Agents - USA
Global
Digital HR Leaders with David Green
David Green
Be Worth* Following
Tim Spiker
HBR On Leadership
Harvard Business Review
Economist Podcasts
The Economist